Feedback is one of a manager's most important tools. Good feedback helps employees understand what they are doing well, what needs to change, and how their behavior affects the team or business results.
The problem is that much workplace feedback is too vague. "Try harder", "communicate better", or "your performance has declined" does not tell an employee what they should actually do differently.
Good feedback is:
Instead of:
"Your communication is poor."
Try:
"During yesterday's meeting, you interrupted Anna twice before she finished explaining her point. This made the discussion harder. In the next meeting, I want us to give each person space to finish before responding."
A simple feedback structure is SBI:
Situation: when and where it happened.
Behavior: what the employee specifically did.
Impact: what happened as a result.
Example:
"During Monday's client meeting, you answered for the client twice before they finished speaking. The client stopped developing the topic, and we had to return to their needs later."
Positive feedback should also be specific.
Instead of:
"Good job."
Try:
"During the client presentation, you handled the pricing questions very effectively. You explained the differences between the options without adding unnecessary detail. That helped us return quickly to the value of the product."
This tells the employee exactly what to repeat.
Do not start by judging the person.
Instead of:
"You are irresponsible."
Try:
"The report was due on Friday. It was not sent, and I did not receive an earlier warning about the issue. When you see a risk of missing a deadline, I need you to raise it before the deadline."
Start with facts.
1. What happened? 2. What was the impact? 3. Why did it happen? 4. What could be done differently? 5. How can we prevent a repeat?
Not every mistake is an employee problem. Sometimes the process is the real problem.
You do not have to force the employee to accept your interpretation.
Try:
"I understand that you see it differently. I would like us to agree on what behavior and outcome are expected."
If the employee provides new facts, the manager should consider them.
Do not say only:
"Your performance is too low."
Instead:
"Over the last two months, you achieved 72% of the agreed target. I would like to understand the main reason for the gap and agree on an improvement plan."
Separate behavior from personality.
Not:
"You are arrogant."
Instead:
"During the meeting, the way you responded to your colleague was perceived as dismissive. I want us to address problems without personal remarks."
Do not stop at praise.
Ask:
"What would you like to repeat from the last project?"
Then move toward development:
"What would you like to take ownership of next?"
Feedback should not happen only during annual performance reviews.
Regular 1:1 meetings are a good place to:
"Improve your communication" does not tell the employee what to change.
The longer the delay, the harder it is to reconstruct the situation accurately.
"You are lazy" is a judgment about the person, not useful feedback.
If a manager speaks up mainly when something is wrong, feedback becomes associated with criticism.
Every useful feedback conversation should answer: "What happens now?"
Use:
Fact → behavior → impact → expectation → next step
Example:
"During the last two meetings \[fact\], you interrupted colleagues \[behavior\], which prevented them from finishing their points \[impact\]. I expect you to let others finish before responding in future meetings \[expectation\]. We will review this after the next meeting \[next step\]."
The best feedback does not end with a judgment. It leads to change.
After the conversation, it can be useful to record:
This is one area where an AI manager assistant can help: organizing conversation notes, retaining commitments, and surfacing topics that should be revisited during the next meeting.
SBI stands for Situation, Behavior, and Impact — a simple structure that helps describe when and where something happened, what the employee specifically did, and what the result was.
Yes. A generic "good job" doesn't tell the employee exactly what to repeat — a specific example helps them reinforce the right behavior.
You don't need to convince them of your interpretation — agree together on what behavior and outcome are expected, and take new facts into account if the employee raises them.
An AI assistant for managers can help organize observations from conversations, retain earlier agreements, and surface topics to revisit at the next meeting.
An AI assistant and manager's notebook: records agreements from 1:1s and keeps track of topics that need follow-up feedback.
Get it on Google Play →
Sidekick